Related pages
Authorship of Isaiah
Traditionally, the book was written by Isaiah the prophet, son of Amoz. Some of the book is written in the first person (ch 6), other narratives are in the third person (ch 7). Some prophecies also involve the prophet himself (eg. 16:9, 21:3-4). The Jews, the New Testament authors and the early church without question always attributed the whole book to Isaiah. However, the authorship of Isaiah is one of the most controversial issues in Biblical scholarship, even among evangelicals.
It is very easy to notice the distinct changes in tone and themes from chapter forty, and again following chapter fifty-six. Each of the three sections also has some unique vocabulary and theological concepts.
Critics say that chapters 40-66 were written later, after the exile to Babylon. One of their main objections to the traditional view is that Cyrus, King of Persia is mentioned by name (44:28 and 45:1), 150 years before he lived, and that the exile is spoken of as a past event. They would date the second half sometime after 536 BC.
Many scholars (probably the majority) suggest a division into two. This was first suggested by Döderlein in 1775:
First Isaiah (Chapters 1-39), otherwise called Proto-Isaiah, or Isaiah of Jerusalem
Second Isaiah (Chapters 40-66), otherwise called Deutero-Isaiah, or Isaiah of Babylon
Some scholars suggest a division into three. This was first suggested by Duhm in 1892:
Proto-Isaiah (chapters 1-39) (740 - 701 BC), known as Isaiah of Jerusalem
Deutero-Isaiah (chapters 40-55), written during during the Babylonian exile, around 550 BC, also referred to Isaiah of Babylon
Trito-Isaiah (chapters 56-66), written after the return from exile, around 500 BC, also referred to another Isaiah of Jerusalem, a disciple of Deutero-Isaiah.
Both views would claim that only chapters 1 to 39 are by Isaiah the prophet, living in Jerusalem in the eighth century BC (700's). Some claim that only parts of chapters 1 to 39 are by Isaiah, particularly excluding the apocalyptic section (ch 24-27).
In both views chapters 40 to 66 are pseudonymous, written by some unnamed prophet (or group of prophets) who was a disciple of Isaiah, living in Babylon during the exile in sixth century (500's), and who could see Cyrus coming. Many scholars suggest there was a school of Isaiah, who continued to think and write in the style of Isaiah. However, there is no evidence for any such school existing. There is great disagreement between scholars, and the theories of authorship become more and more complex.
The presupposition of many scholars is that God cannot predict the future, they deny the supernatural, so they say the prophetic passages must have been written after the event.
Facts used to question single authorship
Chapters 40 to 66 are set in a completely different historical situation from chapters 1 to 39. Chapters 1 to 39 are set in the eighth century BC, with Israel and Judah still existing as independent nations, ruled by a Davidic king, but under threat from Assyria. Chapters 40 to 66 are set in the sixth century BC, towards the end of the Babylonian exile. Assyria no longer exists, and has been replaced by Babylon as world power. It is written from the perspective of seeing the destruction of Jerusalem and the exile as a past event. Jerusalem is in ruins (44:26), her people are far from home (eg. 43:14). The exiles are complaining about their situation (eg. 40:27). A new world power is rising - Persia, led by Cyrus (eg. 44:28).
Other prophets predict the future, but do not normally address their words to people who are living 150 to 200 years into the future, as chapters 40 to 66 do.
There are significant literary differences: chapters 1-39 are condemning and pessimistic, and this changes in chapters 40-66 to consolation and hope, where the language is more lyrical and exalted. There are also biographical differences: chapters 1-39 contain many biographical references to Isaiah personally, but he is not ever mentioned by name in chapters 40-66.
People have commented that if the two parts of the book were not placed together in the OT, probably no one would ever think they were written by the same author.
Problems with multiple authorship view
There is absolutely no evidence that any part of the book ever existed on its own. All manuscripts are of the complete book as we have it. The copy of Isaiah found among the Dead Sea Scrolls contains the complete book. The passage we now call chapter forty continues without the slightest hint of a break from the passage we now call the end of chapter thirty-nine, two lines from the bottom of column 32.
The book of Isaiah is quoted in the NT more than any other OT book. These quotations are from both parts of the book without any differentiation. John quoted from both parts of Isaiah (Jn 12:37-41), quoting Is 53:1 and Is 6:9-10 attributing both to Isaiah. Mark quoted the prophet Isaiah (Is 40:3) in Mk 1:2-3. When Jesus read from Isaiah chapter 61 in the synagogue in Nazareth, Luke refers to the scroll of the prophet Isaiah, "He stood up to read, and the scroll of the prophet Isaiah was given to him." (Lk 4:17).
Late dating cannot explain away the predictions of Jesus, five hundred years later (ch 7, 11, 53 etc), even though they may attempt to explain away predictions of Cyrus.
There are significant similarities in language, style and content in both halves of the book. The phrase 'The Holy One of Israel' is characteristic of Isaiah, found twelve times in chapters 1-39 and fourteen times in chapters 40-66, and only seven times in the whole of the rest of the Bible.
We are also left with the question of how would it be possible for what is normally considered to be the greatest of the OT prophets to be written by an unnamed person, unknown by the Jewish people descended from those he preached to?
Conservative scholars would say that to question the unity of Isaiah questions the accuracy and inerrancy of scripture, especially because of the quotation in John's Gospel referred to above.
Evidence for the unity of the Book of Isaiah
In response to the question about the difference in historical setting, if chapters 40-66 were written during the exile, it would defeat the whole purpose of the setting of the book. The change of viewpoint is precisely because the book is prophetic. Isaiah projected himself into the future, describing future events as if they had already taken place. The exile was predicted to show that God is superior to the other gods and is able to predict the future. Also, to prove to Israel that he is causing the exile, and that he is God. In chapter 41, there is a law-court scene. God challenges the nations to present their case, can they predict the future? "Set forth your case, says the LORD; bring your proofs, says the King of Jacob. Let them bring them, and tell us what is to happen. Tell us the former things, what they are, so that we may consider them, and that we may know their outcome; or declare to us the things to come. Tell us what is to come hereafter; that we may know that you are gods ..." (41:21-23). Throughout the second section of the book, God repeats that he, and he alone, can predict the future, in complete contrast to the idols (45:20, 46:9-10, 48:3).
It is also significant to note that the description of idol worship in chapter 57 is that of pre-exilic Canaanite religion. This does not fit the situation in Israel after the exile, when idolatry was not a major issue any more.
In the Apocryphal book of Ecclesiasticus (Sirach), the hymn in honour of our ancestors includes a description of Hezekiah and Isaiah. It specifically notes that Isaiah was able to declare events in the future. "Hezekiah fortified the city and brought water into its midst; he tunneled the rock with iron tools, and built cisterns for the water. In his days Sennacherib invaded the country; he sent his commander and departed; he shook his fist against Zion, and made great boasts in his arrogance. Then their hearts were shaken and their hands trembled, and they were in anguish, like women in labour. But they called on the Lord who is merciful, spreading out their hands toward him. The Holy One quickly heard them from heaven, and delivered them through Isaiah. The Lord struck down the Assyrians, and his angel wiped them out. For Hezekiah did what was pleasing to the Lord, and he kept firmly to the ways of his ancestor David, as he was commanded by the prophet Isaiah, who was great and trustworthy in his visions. In Isaiah's days the sun went backward, and he prolonged the life of the king. By his dauntless spirit he saw the future and comforted the mourners in Zion. He revealed what was to occur to the end of time, and the hidden things before they happened" (Ecclesiasticus 48:17-25). The author refers to passages in both parts of the Book of Isaiah, making no suggestion that it was a different Isaiah comforting his people, from the Isaiah who encouraged Hezekiah to trust God.
Related pages